Supergirl Is A Solid, Re-Watchable Win (And The Haters Are Fronting)
- Christopher Fagan
- 2 hours ago
- 3 min read
The Direct Take: Don’t Believe the Hate
I just got done watching Supergirl, and honestly? I don’t see what the issue is. I know I might be easier to please than some of the hardcore internet fans out there, but this was a completely solid, entertaining movie. It has high rewatchability, a direct plot, and great performances. Is it the absolute best movie of the year? No, it’s not perfect. But it is an incredibly good time, and I would easily watch it again.
Breaking Down the 'Hater' Mentality
A lot of the online criticism feels like people just wanting to hate for the sake of hating. It’s like the Brie Larson situation all over again—haters latch onto one tiny little nugget and just run with it.
The James Gunn Factor: You can definitely see the "James Gunnisms" in this movie. A lot of fans are mad about the direction he is taking things, but no one is giving specific reasons why.
The Superman Comparison: People keep complaining that he's "ruining it" because they miss Henry Cavill. But that era is over. The irony is that people used to criticize Cavill for being too sad and realistic. Now that James Gunn is bringing back a version of the universe focused on hope, the same people are suddenly complaining that they want the realistic, sad version back. You can't win with these internet critics.
The Plot: Simple, Direct, and Self-Contained
If you look at this movie completely on its own, it works.
The Structure: It has a very clear Point A to Point B. The script might not be flawlessly executed, but the story is simple, confined in its own little world, and moves forward with direct momentum.
The Contrast: If you want to compare it to something, look at the original 1984 Supergirl movie. That had no real budget and no real story. This new film blows it out of the water.
Addressing the "Message" and Female Empowerment
I already know the "red pill" guys are going to get all pissed off and complain about this movie.
The Themes: They are going to claim the movie beats you over the head with a message about human trafficking and girls being victims. But guess what? That actually happens in the real world.
The Ending Surprise: There is a moment at the end where the girls who were captured come through the dust to save the day, saying, "We got you." I thought it was a fantastic, nice little surprise.
The Backlash: Critics are going to compare that moment to the all-female team-up in Avengers: Endgame. But this is a Supergirl movie! She is supposed to be the hero in power. It’s her story, just like Wonder Woman or Xena: Warrior Princess. Having a strong female lead doesn't make Superman look weak. Why do people have such a problem with girls getting just one movie when there are a million male-led superhero films?
Comic Lore & Future Setup (Room for Improvement)
The movie isn’t perfect, and I do have a few minor critiques regarding the lore.
The Survival of Krypton: I liked how they showed the destruction of Krypton, but showing a large piece of the planet surviving with people still alive on it felt a bit different from what I expected.
The Brainiac Theory: Usually, in the comics, it's the villain Brainiac who shrinks a piece of Krypton (Kandor) to save and keep it forever. The way they set this up makes me wonder if this is leading directly into the next Superman movie. It feels like a setup where Brainiac will be introduced, revealing he found that part of Krypton before the radiation killed everyone.
Final Verdict: Stream It
Don't let the loud, specific-yet-vague online hate ruin this for you. It’s an enjoyable, feel-good superhero movie with an awesome lead. My Rating: Definitely Rewatchable.
Comments